Comparing the two fragrances…

Ciel

Orlov
Noir
Elixir
Only in Noir
Only in Elixir
Shared character
Both Noir and Elixir feature a floral profile with shared notes of orange blossom, tuberose, vanilla, and iris/orris.
How they differ
Noir contains unique notes of magnolia, sandalwood, and violet leaves. Elixir contains unique notes of bergamot, amber, and jasmine (sambac).
Who each suits
Noir is suited for those who prefer notes of magnolia, sandalwood, and violet leaves alongside the shared floral elements. Elixir is suited for those who prefer notes of bergamot, amber, and jasmine (sambac) alongside the shared floral elements.