Comparing the two fragrances…

Penhaligon'S

Versace
Heartless Helen
Crystal Noir
Only in Heartless Helen
Shared character
Both Heartless Helen and Crystal Noir belong to the floral family and share a composition of jasmine, tuberose, sandalwood, cashmeran, mandarin, and pink pepper. They both feature floral, woody, fruity, fresh, sweet, and white floral accords.
How they differ
Heartless Helen is characterized by citrus, aldehydic, green, creamy, and animalic accords, utilizing unique notes of woods and woody notes. Crystal Noir presents a different profile through spicy, powdery, oriental, coconut, fresh spicy, lactonic, and warm spicy accords. Its unique note composition includes gardenia, pepper, orange blossom, vanilla, musk, amber, peony, cardamom, fig, ginger, lily of the valley, caramel, violet, blackcurrant bud, heliotropine, blackcurrant, coconut, frangipani, black fig, and akigalawood.
Who each suits
Heartless Helen suits those who prefer citrus, green, and aldehydic profiles with animalic and woody undertones. Crystal Noir suits those drawn to spicy, powdery, and oriental scents featuring lactonic, coconut, and warm vanilla elements.
More Heartless Helen comparisons
Only in Crystal Noir