Comparing the two fragrances…

Fragonard

Tocca
Île D'Amour
Giulietta
Only in Giulietta
Shared character
Both Île D'Amour and Giulietta belong to the floral family and feature shared notes of rose, musk, amber, lily of the valley, and lilac. They both share floral, green, fruity, fresh, musky, and white floral accords.
How they differ
Île D'Amour includes jasmine, osmanthus, and sea water, resulting in citrus, animalic, aromatic, marine, and rose accords. Giulietta contains ylang-ylang, heliotrope, cedarwood, sandalwood, vanilla, iris, orchid, rose (Bulgaria), green apple, iris (pallida), Bulgarian rose, iris, Virginia cedar, vanilla orchid, Granny Smith apple, and pink tulip, which produce woody, sweet, and powdery accords.
Who each suits
Île D'Amour suits those who prefer marine, aromatic, and citrus elements within a floral profile. Giulietta suits those who prefer sweet, powdery, and woody elements within a floral profile.
More Île D'Amour comparisons