Comparing the two fragrances…

HighKey

Replay
That Guy
Essential For Him
Only in That Guy
Only in Essential For Him
Shared character
Both That Guy and Essential For Him feature bergamot and sandalwood. They share citrus, woody, green, fresh, powdery, and aromatic accords.
How they differ
That Guy includes rhubarb, apple blossom, driftwood, and mojito, resulting in floral and fruity accords. Essential For Him contains a wide array of additional notes including jasmine, orange blossom, magnolia, cedarwood, ciste labdanum, vanilla, musk, vetiver, cashmeran, benzoin, amber, cardamom, patchouli, ginger, petitgrain, lily, marine, carnation, cashmere wood, cedar, labdanum, mandarin orange, aquatic notes, amberwood, red berries, red fruits, tolu balsam, sea notes, water notes, and tonka bean. These ingredients contribute spicy, sweet, synthetic, amber, musky, and white floral accords to Essential For Him.
Who each suits
That Guy suits those who prefer fruity and floral profiles. Essential For Him suits those who prefer spicy, sweet, amber, musky, and white floral profiles.