Comparing the two fragrances…

Esprit

Widian
Man
Black III
Shared character
Both Man and Black III belong to the citrus fragrance family and share a base of bergamot, sandalwood, vanilla, patchouli, moss, and dry woods.
How they differ
Man features a profile characterized by fruity, fresh, and marine accords, incorporating notes of apple, pineapple, ginger, violet leaves, lavender, tarragon, vetiver, musk, seawater, leaves, and fern. In contrast, Black III focuses on leather and citrus accords, featuring notes of leather and spearmint.
Who each suits
Man suits those who prefer woody, fruity, creamy, and synthetic fresh profiles with marine and green elements. Black III suits those who prefer leather and citrus-driven profiles.