Comparing the two fragrances…

Class

Creed
Black Man
Aventus
Shared character
Both Black Man and Aventus share a profile of citrus, woody, fruity, leather, and sweet accords. They both feature notes of jasmine, bergamot, vanilla, oakmoss, birch, pineapple, and blackcurrant.
How they differ
Black Man focuses on mossy, vanilla, and white floral accords. Aventus is more complex, incorporating spicy, fresh, smoky, and musky accords. The unique notes in Aventus include lemon, cedarwood, musk, vetiver, mandarin, pink pepper, patchouli, ginger, tonka bean, apple, ambergris, sandalwood (India), jasmine (Morocco), mandarin orange, Indonesian patchouli, styrax, ambroxan, Moroccan jasmine, pink berries, and styrax. While Black Man relies on its shared notes, Aventus utilizes pink pepper and ginger for a bright, spicy opening, and features a base of vetiver, patchouli, and musk.
Who each suits
Black Man suits those who prefer a profile centered on mossy and vanilla elements. Aventus suits those looking for a fragrance with spicy, smoky, and fresh qualities that feature a prominent vetiver and patchouli presence.