Mafia vs Dear Polly

Shared character

Both fragrances feature the notes amber and apple, and they are built around citrus and woody accords. No family classification is provided for either.

How they differ

Mafia contains lemon and patchouli that are not present in Dear Polly, while Dear Polly includes bergamot, musk and oakmoss that Mafia does not have. Both share the same two notes (amber, apple) and the same two accords (citrus, woody), and neither fragrance lists any unique accords or family classifications.

Who each suits

Mafia’s addition of lemon and patchouli makes it a better match for people who enjoy a bright citrus opening combined with an earthy, herbal dry‑down. Dear Polly’s bergamot, musk and oakmoss give it a greener, more mossy profile that may appeal to those who prefer a fresh‑green citrus start that settles into a soft, musky‑oak finish.