Comparing the two fragrances…

Avon

Bath & Body Works
Aqua For Him
Fairytale
Shared character
Both Aqua For Him and Fairytale share a combination of jasmine, bergamot, orange blossom, vanilla, and smoked tea. They are both characterized by woody, sweet, and powdery accords.
How they differ
Aqua For Him features a wide array of notes including sea water, ozonic notes, spearmint, lime, lavender, thyme, geranium, neroli, petitgrain, mate, ylang-ylang, lily, tiare, ambrette seed, mandarin orange, patchouli, vetiver, cedar, moss, castanea sativa, benzoin, musk, and skin accord, resulting in aquatic, fresh, aromatic, fresh spicy, marine, musky, rose, and salty accords. Fairytale contains oakmoss, amber, cardamom, green tea, gaiac wood, pomegranate, and glimzorith, which produce citrus, amber, animalic, vanilla, and white floral accords.
Who each suits
Aqua For Him suits those who prefer aquatic, marine, and aromatic profiles with fresh, salty, and herbal elements. Fairytale suits those who prefer citrus, amber, and white floral profiles with animalic and vanilla undertones.
More Aqua For Him comparisons
Only in Fairytale