Comparing the two fragrances…

Atkinsons London 1799

Balmain
Shine Despite Everything
Rose De Soie
Only in Shine Despite Everything
Shared character
Both Shine Despite Everything and Rose De Soie belong to the floral fragrance family and share the notes of Ambrofix, Akigalawood, and Rosyfolia.
How they differ
Shine Despite Everything features notes of iris, Madagascar vanilla, caramel, Somali incense, coumarin, turmeric, and allspice. Rose De Soie contains rose, orange blossom, elemi, musk, pink pepper, peony, tonka bean, suede, coffee, and petalia.
Who each suits
Shine Despite Everything suits those who prefer notes of iris, vanilla, caramel, and incense. Rose De Soie suits those who prefer notes of rose, orange blossom, peony, suede, and coffee.
More Shine Despite Everything comparisons
Only in Rose De Soie