Comparing the two fragrances…

Armaf

Halloween
Q Donna
Shot
Shared character
Both Q Donna and Shot share a profile defined by floral, fruity, and gourmand accords. They both feature notes of jasmine, vanilla, patchouli, caramel, passion fruit, violet, and mandarin orange, resulting in a sweet scent profile.
How they differ
Q Donna includes a variety of citrus, white floral, and creamy elements such as lemon, gardenia, rose, orange blossom, magnolia, freesia, peach, coconut, praline, and musk. Shot is characterized by the addition of rose water and hazelnut, and is noted for its synthetic accords.
Who each suits
Q Donna suits those who prefer a profile featuring creamy, powdery, and white floral notes alongside citrus and musk. Shot suits those who prefer a scent profile incorporating rose water and hazelnut.
Only in Shot